Showing posts with label CRTPO. Show all posts
Showing posts with label CRTPO. Show all posts

Friday, December 11, 2015

End a big week with your comments to CRTPO!

This Monday, the anti-toll movement put a big exclamation point on last month's elections.  At the swearing-in ceremonies in Huntersville and Cornelius the newly sworn Boards ratcheted up the pressure against the toll project.

In Huntersville, after an historic election that saw the defeat of an incumbent Mayor and two incumbent Commissioners based largely on their support of the I77 HOT lanes project, the new Board unanimously passed a strongly worded resolution asking that the contract for the project be “terminated”.  The resolution included 13 different reasons, or “whereas” clauses, for requesting NCDOT terminate the contract.

In Cornelius, things were a bit more personal with the new Board apparently considering a resolution criticizing Mayor Chuck Travis’s quasi-official actions supporting the project in contradiction to the Board majority’s long standing opposition to it.  A vote on a resolution was deferred, but even considering it as one of the new Board’s first items for discussion sends a clear message.

However, even with these strong moves, not everything has been going smoothly for the community effort to defeat the tolls.

The details behind the previously announced “Select Committee” in the NC House to discuss the subject were released last Friday.  Those details failed to inspire confidence that the Committee will lead to any quick action.  The committee is made up of 20 members and has a charter to look at all sorts of transportation issues, not just the I77 project.  It also includes members of who are known supporters of the HOT lanes such as Mooresville Rep John Fraley.

Also, the recent “I77 Summit” held in Cornelius in late November failed to draw Governor McCrory’s attendance.  Instead, he sent the usual suspects from the NCDOT to rehash their same talking points.  He also continued to hide behind the actions of the region’s main transportation planning body, the CRTPO - saying only that body had the authority to cancel the project – a position which would seem to undermine his own authority as Governor.

So, while clearly the local opposition is gaining steam there is just as clearly much more work to do if the powers that be in Raleigh are to be convinced this project needs to be re-thought.

As luck would have it, an opportunity for citizens to contribute to that work is currently underway.

Every four years the Federal Department of Transportation reviews how the various regional Metropolitan Planning Organizations are doing.  In this area, that body is the Charlotte Regional Transportation Planning Organization, or CRTPO.  The public comment period for this quadrennial review of the CRTPO runs through next Wednesday, December 15th.

Local citizens should have plenty to say regarding how the body has handled this issue.

Who can forget former Huntersville Commissioner Sarah McAulay serving as the CRTPO Chair and unilaterally shutting down toll opponents during the public hearing on the HOT lanes?  Her actions as the Chair of the body in general as well as during this public hearing specifically have a great deal to do with why she is a “former” Commissioner.

Who can forget the CRTPO ignoring over 700 comments opposing the project before the body voted to approve it?  Defying common sense, the CRTPO actually approved a toll project without giving the public any clear idea what the actual tolls would be.

Who can forget Charlotte – which holds a near majority of the votes on the CRTPO -  snubbing the Lake Norman area municipalities and not even bothering to attend the recent “I77 Summit”?  The City’s actions show a clear problem with how CRTPO is structured in that Charlotte really does not have to listen to the other members, and city leaders have proven they won't.

The November press release from CRTPO says the Federal review is to ensure it “follows a continuing, cooperative, and comprehensive transportation planning process.”  Based on the above examples, the body sure seems to fall short on at least a couple of those points.

To provide your own comments, send an email to Loretta.Barren@dot.gov with the Federal Highway Administration by December 15th.

This column first appeared in this week's Herald Weekly at HuntersvilleHerald.com.

Saturday, November 28, 2015

Feds taking comments on CRTPO...give 'em an ear full.

In the aftermath last week's "I77 Summit", the region's primary transportation planning body, the CRTPO, has become the center of attention when it comes to the I77 HOT lanes project.

The Governor is hiding behind the group, saying the only way he'll consider stopping the project is if the CRTPO tells him to do it.  The NCDOT is saying any newly constituted CRTPO body would not be able to reasonably decide the issue quickly because the body could have several new faces after this month's elections.  If any actionable item did come out of the "Summit", it was Rep Charles Jeter's stated intention to file a bill to reduce Charlotte's influence in the CRTPO when the Legislature reconvenes for its short session next year.  The Charlotte Observer has even recognized that the City's decision to skip the summit looks bad and jeopardizes the legitimacy its current setup as a decision making body.

Charlotte has long used its weighted voting power to effectively make decisions in all but unilateral fashion for the entire region.  As we said in this story here back in 2013, Charlotte often acts like the playground bully effectively saying "we'll take our ball and go home if we don't get our way".

Frankly, there has been little that individuals can do about that setup.  That is, up until now.

WidenI77.org is encouraging the public to send the below email (or any respectful email of your choosing) to the Federal Department of Transportation before December 15.  The quadrennial review period for the CRTPO is currently underway at the Federal level and the DOT is taking comments.

Send your email to Loretta.Barren@dot.gov and let the Feds know how the current setup is effectively allowing Charlotte to milk the surrounding region while not allowing the surrounding region an effective mechanism to stop it - or at least to be treated fairly.

Sample email below...

Subject: CRTPO Public Involvement Process

Dear Ms. Barren-
The CRTPO is in need of reform. During the past several years they have minimized or ignored public input. With a very lop-sided voting structure, one city benefits greatly while the needs of the other towns and the region are ignored.
For example:

  • During the July 2015 public comment period, CRTPO received over 700 individual comments opposing the P3.0 TIP.  CRTPO approved the TIP citing, among other reasons, the fact that the TIP had to be approved quickly or they risked losing federal allocation in October.  Therefore, the public comment period was moot.

  • While developing the P4.0 project list, CRTPO received over 250 public comments urging adoption.  At their September 16, 2015 meeting, CRTPO took the extremely unusual step of postponing approval. In direct opposition to public comments, CRTPO subsequently removed a project from the list and approved the list at their next meeting.

  • On May 23, 2013 CRTPO (then MUMPO) Chairwoman Sarah MacAulay unilaterallydenied all citizens the opportunity to comment during the public comment period. Eighteen had signed up to speak on the controversial I-77 private toll project.

  • At their December 12, 2013 CRTPO meeting, TCC staff recommended against including a public comment period for TCC meetings.  CRTPO accepted this recommendation. A public comment period for TCC meetings does not exist.

  • The public comment period policy for MUMPO meetings used to be three minutes per person and ten minutes per group. CRTPO revised this to limit the public comment period to twenty minutes total, regardless of the number of speakers or groups.
  • Groups wishing to make a formal presentation must notify CRTPO ten days in advance.

  • Mr. Ned Curran serves as an alternate delegate for NCDOT Divisions 10 & 12. Curran is also Chairman of the NCDOT Board and CEO of Bissel, a major land developer and property manager in South Charlotte. On August 19, 2015, Curran voted for the P3.0 TIP as the Division 12 delegate. I believe it is a conflict of interest for a major land developer to decide road and transportation improvement projects.

  • Ms. Sarah McAulay serves as Chair of CRTPO. On August 19, 2015, McAulay introduced a motion to approve the P3.0 TIP which includes seven Huntersville projects. McAulay owns or co-owns three properties with direct frontage to at least one or more of the projects and six properties in close proximity to one or more projects.  I believe it is aconflict of interest for a CRTPO member to decide road improvement projects from which they may directly benefit.
These comprise serious flaws in the CRTPO’s planning process, have seriously eroded public trust and fail to serve the public interest. Per 23 U.S.C. (i)(5) and 49 U.S.C. 1607 I am therefore requesting you reject CRTPO’s certification until substantial reforms are completed.

Sincerely,

Name

Town

Wednesday, August 19, 2015

BREAKING NEWS: Davidson to vote 'NO' at CRTPO tonight!

This is a breaking news story. More information will be added if it becomes available.

In a phone call from Davidson Commissioner Brian Jenest early this morning, he indicated that Davidson will be a 'no' vote on the STIP at tonight's CRTPO meeting.

At last week's Davidson Board meeting he indicated that he would be a 'yes' vote on this issue.

He explained the change as not so much a change in his position as just a change in his vote.  His position has been that he supports the STIP, but does not support this paricular plan for the managed lanes.

When asked why he was going to change his vote, he responded that while he is not typically supportive of "protest votes' he recognizes how widespread the public opposition to this particular plan has become. Also, he mentioned what occurred at last night's Lake Norman Chamber meeting.

At that meeting he heard "level-headed businessmen" open to alternative plans that may involve the managed lane concept.  For him, that opened the door to other possibilities and justified the change in his vote.

While Davidson's single vote on the CRTPO  board may not make a difference in the ultimate outcome of the vote, it is great to see the town's representative standing up for what the people he represents actually want!

Ron Julian loves HOT lanes! Where is Jill Swain's outrage?!?!

Almost exactly a year ago, Huntersville Commissioner Rob Kidwell sent an email to state legislators asking them to do something, anything, to stop the I77 HOT lanes project.

Well, late on the eve of a critical vote at the CRTPO fellow H'ville Commish, Ron Julian, did something similar.

In an email to CRTPO reps, Charlotte City Council, the MeckBOCC, and several members of the NCGA, Julian had this to say.

" Ladies and Gentle, As a Representative of the constituents in Huntersville, I ask that you APPROVE the TIP ( Vote Yes ). The vast majority of constituents want road improvements now and the TIP keeps this promise with dollars for local road improvements and additional lanes, yes managed lanes on I-77.

thanks for your public service,

Ron Julian
Huntersville Town Commissioner
"

My guess is you'll hear crickets from Mayor Swain on this one.  She agrees after all.

She's part of the HOT Lanes Bucket Brigade that has pulled this monstrosity out of the fire more than once already.

Sending Ron Julian to carry a little water since he's not running for reelection is just what a good brigade commander does.

Bonus Observation:  What caused Ron Julian to change his mind since this video in 2013?

Wednesday, August 5, 2015

Mike Angell, Davidson's newest candidate, on CRTPO vote and tolls

I had the chance to speak with Mike Angell for the first time this evening.  Angell is the sole non-incumbent running for Davidson's Board this November.

Here's what he had to say on the issues of a directed vote and how he would vote if he was on the Board currently.

Angell said he opposed the idea of a directed vote, taking the position that if you can't trust the person to vote the way the Board wants, then you have the wrong person in that position to represent the Board.

When asked how the public would know a representative had voted the way a majority of the Board wanted, Angell said he'd be open to a non-binding vote of the Board on the issue of accepting the current TIP.  If the CRTPO rep (Brian Jenest) then voted against the Board's wishes, that would be clear.

Finally, when asked how he would vote in such a non-binding resolution if he was a Commissioner, he said he would vote against supporting the current TIP if it included the current HOT project.

Angell clarified that he's not totally opposed to the idea of tolls.  However, he does oppose the current P3 HOT plan.  He does not like the dynamic tolling process, the use of a foreign company in the P3 which takes money out of the state, the increase in passengers required from HOV-2 to HOT-3, and the use of a 50 year P3 contract for I77 versus the state managed toll proposals for other interstates in the Charlotte area.

So, there you have it.  Davidson's newest person on the political scene would support efforts to stop the current I77 proposal while not being completely anti -toll.

Wednesday, May 20, 2015

CRTPO Meeting Tonight - Will they dump HOT Lanes

With Mecklenburg County now on-board with postponing the HOT lanes project on I77 until thhe contract is audited for more irregularities, our state Rep John Bradford has stepped into the fray.  After Tuesday's vote he posted the below on the LKN Election Connection Facebook page.

"I am respectfully encouraging all CRTPO members to work to amend their agenda tomorrow night and formally consider asking the NCDOT for a delay in the financial close of the I-77 project. The ground rules of this project have changed with the introduction of a possible new funding option (i.e. bonds) since MUMPO (now called CRTPO) decided back in 2007 to sanction a Fast Lanes study that would ultimately recommend express managed lanes. I do not think this group of elected officials would have made the same decision if they knew that a possible third funding option (i.e. bonds) was a possibility. It seems to me that a request for a delay in the project's closing is very reasonable and it would send a clear message to NCDOT that the decision over 7 years ago to support managed lanes was made under a very different set of funding possibilities."

Of course, after revealing Tuesday night that he cannot vote on the project, Mecklenburg County's, Dumont Clarke should not vote not be the project as the county's CRTPO member.  At the Tuesday MeckBOCC meeting Clarke had to admit publicly that he has a conflict of interest on the toll road project via his firm's involvement with a client.  Clarke recused himself from voting on the MeckBOCC amendment.  Clarke works for high powered law firm Moore and Van Allen.

If you are interested in supporting Rep Bradford in his request CRTPO change course, email members at the below addresses asking them to include a vote on a HOT lanes resolution in tonight's agenda.

Huntersville Commissioner Sarah McAulay chairs the body.  She can put this on the agenda if she wants to do so.  Hers is the first address.

sMcAulay@huntersville.org, brad.s.horvath@wellsfargo.com, pcnrb01@yahoo.com, vlyles@charlottenc.gov, wtwasham@cornelius.org, bjenest@colejeneststone.com, jbiggers@charlottepipe.com, gsavoie@council.indiantrail.org, ken.robertson@dsm.com, ntcarp@windstream.net, lannyopenshaw@marvinnc.org, jtaylor@matthewsnc.com, dumontclarke@mvalaw.com, dena.diorio@mecklenburgcountync.gov, msncmayor@yahoo.com, bwelch@admin.minthill.com, dnash@monroenc.org, edingler@ci.mooresville.nc.us, tracy.dodson@lincolnharris.com, lswetmore@ncdot.gov, lgladden@pinevilledsl.net, wdunn@council.stallingsnc.org, ehr413@gmail.com, michaeljohnson@earthlink.net, richard.helms@co.union.nc.us, duane.gardner@waxhaw.com, bdeter@townofweddington.com, bgbraswell@hotmail.com, reschert@aol.com, btrimbur@cornelius.org, rgraham@ci.davidson.nc.us, elong@fairviewnc.gov, jswain@huntersville.org, johnsonspartssup@att.net, joepollino@marvinnc.org, joseph.pata@bankofamerica.com, jim.puckett@mecklenburgcountync.gov, jbclivingwater@windstream.net, minthillmickey@carolina.rr.com, bkilgore@monroenc.org, lqualls@ci.mooresville.nc.us, ncurran@bissellcompanies.com, WKline@council.stallingsnc.org, ckutteh@popemcmillan.com, phenkel@roadrunner.com, lance.simpson@co.union.nc.us, steve.maher@waxhaw.com, barbarafarrison@townofweddington.com, jeanninekenary@wesleychapelnc.com, jbmoser@carolina.rr.com